Tuesday, June 3, 2014

11. Ethnolinguistics of Senegal, or, ‘What’s a Jaxanké?’



The language that I ‘speak’ (read: stumble through) and am always learning here in Senegal is called Jaxanké, (sometimes transcribed as Diahanké, Jaxanke, and Diaxango). It is the same language as Malinké—we have the same dictionary, took the same language classes during PST—except not quite, as Malinké and Jaxanké are separate ethnic groups. For anyone interested, the following is a bit on how this ethno linguistic group fits into the socio-ethnic history and geography of Western Africa.

The subject matter of this post may not be especially riveting for someone who is not either personally or academically familiar with West Africa.  So to spice things up I have included pictures of babies from my village playing with fire, accompanied by Nietzsche quotes. Think of them as New Yorker cartoons. (Inspired by http://www.nietzschefamilycircus.com/)

Before arriving in Senegal, I assumed that all PC volunteers here learned Wolof. This is the common language for the majority of the country, a lingua franca. 
In fact, the Peace Corps teaches volunteers a handful of what we call ‘local languages,’ in order to match, to some extent, Senegal’s linguistic diversity.
Wolofs are about 43% of the population of Senegal. They are followed by Pulaars of various stripes, 24% (or perhaps more according to many estimates), Serers, 15%, Diolas, at about 5%, Mandés of many different types are somewhere around 4%, and a whole cocktail of various minorities make up the last 2%.[1] (The Wikipedia page doesn’t add up to 100% either)

He who fights with monsters should look to it that he
 himself does not become a monster. And when you
gaze long into an abyss the abyss also gazes into you.
Wolof is the lingua franca in Senegal for a couple reasons. First, since the Wolofs comprise almost half of the population of Senegal. Thus they form a plurality, which gives them an obvious head start as cultural hegemons.
Secondly, they are more concentrated in cities than other groups, especially the cities in the western 1/3rd of the country, where 5/6ths of the country’s population resides. The Wolofs have capitalized on their position as well connected urbanites to dominate most of the business and industry in the country.
Economic preeminence tends to lead to cultural and linguistic hegemony. This is happening in Kédougou, a land that has long been Malinké/Jaxanké and Pulaar. An example of this is amongst the employees of foreign gold-mining companies here in Kedougou. These companies establish offices in Dakar, and subcontract security and labor to Wolof companies also based in Dakar, whose Wolof employees have thus come flooding into Kédougou.

Another Wolof economic foothold in Kédougou, and across the entire country is the public transportation system. This is comprised of a network of ‘garages’ where one can pay for a spot in a buses, mini-buses, or station-wagons that run to other garages in cities all over the country. The Mouride Brotherhood, which is a Wolof dominated religious group, has a total monopoly on this transportation network, and no matter where you are going to or from, your driver is guaranteed to be Wolof.
Thus, due in large part to higher rates of urbanization, and a dominant economic position, Wolofs have a more homogenous and widespread cultural identity than any other ethnic group in Senegal. 'Wolof culture,' many would argue, has come to be considered the national culture of Senegal. This is known as the ‘Wolofisation’ of Senegal, and some people are starting to complain about it.

The next biggest ethno linguistic/cultural group in Senegal is Pulaar.[2] This is probably the biggest ethno linguistic group in West Africa. In Senegal, they come in three flavors; The Pulaar de Nords are concentrated along the Senegal River valley in the north; The Fula Kunda, also known as Fouladou, pretty much all live in the Casamance, south of The Gambia; And the Pula Futa, emanate from the Guinean Plateau into Kedougou and parts of Kolda.
The Pulaars are a fascinating people, much too fascinating to attempt to discuss in any great length right here. They extend throughout the Sahelian region of Africa from Senegal to Ethiopia, and south through Guinea into Liberia and Sierra Leone.  They originated as a nomadic herding people, and have historically played a large part in bridging the Sahara desert, centuries before the arrival of Europeans, trading extensively with Berbers and Arabs in the north, and dozens of different groups in the south. Historically, because of their disparate nomadic lifestyle, the Pulaars formed only very loose political association. Before the coming of Islam, Pulaar states, beyond regional tribute based kingdoms were largely unknown.
We cannot help but see Socrates as the turning-point,
 the vortex of world history.
The Pulaar people are believed to have originated in what is now northern Senegal/ Southern Mauritania. Over hundreds of years they came to inhabit the vast territory of the Sahel through a series of migrations. These migrations took various forms. Generally they were slow, nomadic drifts into empty spaces in search of new pasturelands.
 There have also been instances of more intentional Pulaar migrations, specifically via what are known as the ‘Pulaar Jihads’. However, it is wrong to consider the ‘Pulaar Jihads’ to somehow be a distinctive, congruous event. They were entirely multifarious, and connected only loosely if at all, with highly variable, inconsistent levels of violence, tactics, and motivation.
Pulaar migrations have continued well into modern times, though the Jihaads are long since over. One of the most significant modern movements of Pulaar people took place throughout the 60s, 70s and 80s after Ahmed Sékou Touré took power in Conakry.
Touré was the only leader in Africa to deny France’s invitation to join the Communité Français. In doing this he seemed to represent a real hope for a truly independent post-colonial African leader, one who had the courage to truely stand up to former colonial powers. His early rhetoric in the 1960s was Marxist-utopian, and deeply inspired by the socialist hopes of the time. His writings are still standard in any study of Marxism in Africa.

Regrettably, the promise of a bright post-independence Guinea was not to last. It was torn apart when Touré began exploiting ethnic divides in order to maintain power. This was a dangerous thing to do in a deeply fractured, desperately poor, and economically dysfunctional post-colonial state. To make a long story short, Touré is ethnically Mandé, which is another broad ethno linguistic group (we will talk about them soon). The Mandés make up about 35% of the population of Guinea, while Pulaars make up 45%. As post-independence hopes of prosperity rapidly began to disintegrate, for myriad reasons, such as a lack of functional institutions or infrastructure whatsoever, Touré quickly began to militarize the state apparatus.
Mathematics would certainly have not come into
 existence if one had known from the beginning that
there was in nature no exactly straight line,
no actual circle, no absolute magnitude.
Because his state was failing Touré was quickly challenged politically by the Front de Libération Nationale de Guinea (FLNG), an opposition party. It just so happens that many prominent figures in the FLNG were Pulaars. Touré then decided that there was a Pulaar plot to assassinate or overthrow him, and he responded in increasingly erratic and vicious ways. His military forces began rounding up anyone suspected of being a dissident, especially Pulaars, and throwing them into, (no typo here) concentration camps.

The most notorious of these was Camp Boiro, located on an island near the capital, Conakry. Estimates of the total number of people killed by Tourés regime are hard to establish, but an organization called “Children of the Victims of Boiro Camp” has leveled an estimate of 50,000.
Pulaars all over the country were targeted in various forms by Touré’s policies of political paranoia, and thousands fled into Senegal, a more stable nation. Precise, or even semi-precise numbers of those who fled will never be known, for these migrations were both informal and illegal, and often motivated by factors other than the violence against Pulaars in Guinea. What we do know is that it made the region of Kédougou majority Pulaar, although it was probably primarily Mandé speaking as recently as 1960. Many of the Pulaar villages in Kedougou are named after villages in Guinea, having been founded by fleeing/migrating residents of the latter.  

The Serers (15% of the population of Senegal) are concentrated along along the coast from the region of Dakar south, into The Gambia, and northern Ziganchor. The Serer language is unique; it is not closely related to any other languages. These coastal fishing people are said to be the first people of modern Senegal, perhaps even sub-Saharan Africa, to have extensive contact with Europeans.
This initial prolonged contact between the Serers and Europeans (mostly Portuguese) took place very early-- the late 1400’s-- so early, in fact, that the Serers had not yet been converted in any significant proportion to Islam. They were therefore among Africa's first Christian converts, and continue to have a higher proportion of Christians than most of Senegal’s ethnic groups.
 These unique geographic and cultural circumstances have made the Serers disproportionately influential in the political affairs of the country. During the colonial era the French utilized religious cleavage and favored Christian Serers as colonial bureaucrats. The Serers therefore gained access earlier, and in greater numbers to the institutions that the Europeans brought with them, like education. It is no surprise then that the first president, the poet and intellectual Leopold Sedar Senghor, was a Christian Serer[3]. Many people maintain that to this day the Serers still enjoy much higher rates of governmental representation than other groups.   
Free will without fate is no more conceivable
than spirit without matter, good without evil
.

So I learned much of this before the language assignments came. I thought I was pretty hip to the linguistic situation in Senegal. Then when languages were announced during Pre-Service Training, I was assigned ‘Jaxanké.’ I did not know what that was! Imagine, being told that you are going to learn and live in a language that you did not know existed. I had a million questions, and slowly I have been able to answer many of them.

 Jaxanké is a minority language in Senegal, spoken exclusively in the south eastern, regions of the country. It is probably the least widely spoken of all 7 languages taught by Peace Corps Senegal.
However, Jaxanké is part of the Mandé language family, which is one of the largest, most diverse ethno linguistic groups in West Africa. The Mandé family includes dozens of different individual languages that stretch across West Africa. [4] In Senegal alone, the Mandé family is represented by Mandinka, Bambara, Jalonké, Soninké, Malinké, Dyula and others.[5] [6] However, only a fraction of each of these groups live in Senegal, which is why, despite being a very large ethnic group, Mandés only comprise about 4% of the population of Senegal (according to Wikipedia).
The Mandé ethnic group originated in what is now southwestern Mali. The Mandé people emanated from this heartland in a number of ways, most significantly through the rise of the Malian Empire.
The story of the founding of the Malian empire is told in the tale of Sundiata. This tale was passed down from generation to generation by the story-telling musician class; griots, or in Jaxanké, Jali. It is still a widely known tale that almost any Mandé can tell you something about. It is considered ‘semi-historical’ by academics, who have reproduced the epic in various published forms, which is how I came to know it. I hope, someday, to hear the story straight from the mouth of a griot, accompanied by music. (Unfortunately in my small village there is no Jali)

Sundiata Keita amassed a great army and unified various West African Kingdoms into what was thus known as the Malian Empire, said to have been founded in 1230. It grew steadily for the first one hundred years of its existence, then declined and fractured slowly until it finally ceased to exist in 1600.
The empire at its greatest extent, circa ~1300.


The Malian Empire reached its greatest height under Emperor Mansa Musa, (Mansa actually means King, so ‘Emporer Mansa Musa’ is a little redundant) who came to power in 1280. Musa was an exceptional fellow, and he came to power at an exceptional time of an extremely wealthy, prosperous empire. He was also very ambitious, and a competent, strong willed ruler. He fostered and expanded the trade of his empire to the point where he came to control approximately one half of the worldwide trade in gold and salt.
It is stated by many sources that Mansa Musa was the richest person to have ever lived.

Wait. What?

It is obviously very difficult to compare wealth through different historical ages. However, if you take the most simple, straightforward and oldest measure of wealth; amount of gold one owns, Musa had more wealth, plain and simple, than anyone else. Ever.

He is best known for his pilgrimage to Mecca, a voyage whose extravagance may have no historical analog. He embarked with 60,000 people, including 12,000 slaves who each carried a four-pound bar of gold.

Art is the supreme task and the truly
metaphysical activity in this life
Every Friday, rather than simply stopping for a day of rest and prayer, he actually funded the construction of a mosque. He gave away small pouches of gold dust to beggars in Cairo, In fact, Musa spent and gave away so much gold throughout the trip that the world wide price of gold plummeted, effectively destroying economies throughout the middle east and north Africa. The records of merchants and historians across the Mediterranean and Middle Eastern remark on this precipitous decline in gold prices. It is speculated, by some that he may have ‘inadvertently funded the Italian Renaissance,’ as Genoan and Venician traders bought the metal at cost and brought it back to north Italy.

The Malian Empire reached reached all the way to the Atlantic Ocean (modern day coast of Senegal) long before Musa came to power, under the leadership of Abubakari II. This guy decided that he wanted to know what lay beyond this great ocean. 

An Egyptian scholar of the day, Al-Umari once asked Mansa Musa about this. The great leader responded;

The ruler who preceded me did not believe that it was impossible to reach the extremity of the ocean that encircles the earth (the Atlantic Ocean). He wanted to reach that (end) and was determined to pursue his plan. So he equipped two hundred boats full of men, and many others full of gold, water and provisions sufficient for several years. He ordered the captain not to return until they had reached the other end of the ocean, or until he had exhausted the provisions and water. So they set out on their journey. They were absent for a long period, and, at last just one boat returned. When questioned the captain replied: 'O Prince, we navigated for a long period, until we saw in the midst of the ocean a great river which flowing massively. My boat was the last one; others were ahead of me, and they were drowned in the great whirlpool and never came out again. I sailed back to escape this current.' But the Sultan would not believe him. He ordered two thousand boats to be equipped for him and his men, and one thousand more for water and provisions. Then he conferred the regency on me for the term of his absence, and departed with his men, never to return nor to give a sign of life.
—Mansa Musa (From Wikipedia)
How interesting. 
So, over the years, the Malian empire did all of the things that empires usually do. It expanded with lofty ambition, through both war and trade, and it spread its language, culture, religion, and people throughout its territory. This is a large part of how Mandé speaking people came to cover the entire area of the empire, which began a steady decline shortly after Musa’s extravagant reign.
Even in those days, ‘Mandé’ was a very diverse ethno linguistic group. Some Mandé languages were mutually intelligible, and some were not, and many distinct identities within this group emerged even before the empire spread the Mandé diaspora all over West Africa. 
This map should help confuse you


The Soninké (alternatively called Sarakolé), shown on the map, were a distinct Mandé group before the Malian Empire came to be. Out of the Soninké ethnic group, a caste of religious elites arose, Islamic clerics, who soon began to establish for themselves a distinct identity, living in ‘religion and tillage.’[7] These people were some of the very earliest Muslims in West Africa, and trace their lineage to Uqbah b. Nafi, an Arab who was “chosen by Allah to conquer Ifriqya as far as Ghana.”[8]  

These were the Jaxankés.

In the 12th or 13th century a man named al-Hajj Salim Suware led the Jaxankés south and west from Soninké lands into the Futa Jallon[9] (Present day Kédougou!) where he ‘established a clerical republic of enduring fame and prestige.’[10] When the Malian empire swept across the land, the “Jaxanké republic was respected as a holy centre over which the king’s edict had no force.” [11] Their towns were in many cases university towns, attracting scholars of the Koran from all over the region. I think that this is extremely cool. Al-Hajj Salim Suware emphasized pacifism as a tenant of clerical life, and rejected political involvement. As Wikipedia puts it:
The Jakhanke cultural ethos is best characterized by a staunch dedication to Islam, historical accuracy, rejection of jihad, non-involvement in political affairs and the religious instruction of young people.[12]

Over time, the Jaxanké came to be regarded as a fully independent branch of the Soninké people from which they sprang, and came to adopt the language of a neighboring people, the Malinké, which is also a Mandé group. This is what I meant when I said that Malinké and Jaxanké is the same language, but different people.
Everything which distinguishes man from the
animals depends upon this ability to volatilize
 perceptual metaphors in a schema,
and thus to dissolve an image into a concept
The Jaxankés also came to develop a trade diaspora that stretched from the interior lands of the Futa Jallon to a wide swath of the West African coast. They were generally successful in their business endeavors, thanks to hard work, effective networking, and a reputation, due to their piousness, for being honest in trade and commerce.
Over the centuries the Jaxankés have maintained a strong and independent cultural identity. Their dedication to pacifism and political non-engagement was tested, but ultimately uncompromised by the coming of European imperialism. Although some scholars maintain that this was largely due to their cultural and geographic isolation, rather than cultural conviction. The coming of Pulaars in the ~17th century, who quickly became a culturally dominant majority in the Futa Jallon, was probably a bigger test of their cultural tenacity.
Today the Jaxankés enjoy, as I have mentioned, a reputation for hard work, religious piety, and a strong scholarly tradition. That is my village in a nutshell. Volunteers in Pulaar villages around mine are constantly blown away by how quickly and ambitiously people in my village go about their work. Senegalese everywhere, at least those who have heard of the Jaxankés[13] will confirm; Jaxankés work hard.
 I don’t mean to defend my ‘own group’ at the expense of any other, this really isn’t about that. I am just conferring my experience and the experience of other volunteers. And the Jaxanké reputation has its flipside, in the form of a negative stereotype. Many Senegalese, particularly those who do not actually live near Jaxankés, or even know any, will often claim that all Jaxankés care about are godo, muso, subo; money, women, meat; that they are greedy, and have an undue, disproportionate share of the country’s wealth.
Sound familiar? A trade Diaspora. A strong, relatively narrow religious tradition. A reputation for hard work and intelligence, and, simultaneously, greed. Considering these things, myself, and a few other academically engaged PC Sengegal friends, cannot help but think of the Jaxankés as the Jews of West Africa. There are of course numerous issues with this comparison, notably the much more urban-based history and culture of the Jews, but I think that this is something to it. (But note that I cite no academic sources here)
We are, all of us, growing volcanoes that
approach the hour of their eruption; but how
 near or distant that is, nobody knows — not even God.
So I live in a fascinating place, with a fascinating group of people. Knowing all of this history enlivens my daily experience. Now I see the long hours of drone-like reading from the Koran as the continuation of a long and successful tradition, and I have reconsidered my conviction that learning French is a better thing for the kids here than learning Arabic—although this is still a very difficult question for me.
Right now the rainy season is beginning. The first heavy rain came on the 15th of May, and within 5 days my village had already planted many hectares of corn, cassava and peanuts. I have been looking and asking around, and know of no other villages that planted so much land so quickly/early. Most villages in the area are still repairing fences and have only planted small patches of corn. The farmers in my village will be the first people to have corn on the market, and will get higher prices for it. Planting so early was a gamble though, because sometimes the first rain is followed by weeks of dryness, but we got just enough rain in late May to bridge the gap, and now the rains are coming with increasing regularity. 
The village has also gotten together and is going to rent a tractor for the entire rainy season to facilitate the farming of rice. My host dad also purchased a horse[14], which plows land about twice as fast as donkeys or cows. The village is also building a big bridge right now to replace the stick bridge, which already broke in a flood.
These are just some of the projects that are underway in my village right now. I am consistently blown away by the work ethic in my village, and the ambition.  The people are diligent, motivated, and have a real sense of purpose. And they love their work. They believe in it too.
They believe in the power of work to improve their lives and the lives of their children. Unfortunately this is really not the case in much of Kedougou and Senegal. In many villages near the gold mines, people hear of miners striking it rich and decide to go try their luck, abandoning agriculture and other trades.
Thoughts are the shadows of our feelings —
 always darker, emptier, simpler.
 In other villages, the saturation of NGOs seems to have diminished people’s motivation.  Why would you work when the western donors are willing to dump all kinds of goods and money on your village? And sometimes things are quite literally dumped onto villages. One volunteer in the nearby town of Bandafassi told me of a time he was sitting with some people in town, talking, when a truck representing a Spanish NGO drove up. The truck stopped, and someone shoved about 20 new bikes, tied together with rope, out of the back onto the ground. Then the truck drove away. 
Needless to say, this volunteer was very frustrated with the people in his village, and had great difficulty getting them to cooperate on any manner of work project. This is an unfortunate but very real and widespread result of well meaning NGOs.
Meanwhile I feel incredibly lucky with the work partners I get to collaborate with. I get full support for almost any project I propose. With rainy season coming on, work is rapidly picking up, and I am spending many happy days out in the fields, living, amongst the continued tradition of one of one of West Africa’s most successful cultural groups. 


[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Senegal
[2] Who are also known by dozens of other appelations such as Fulani, Peul, Fulbe, etc
[3] An amazing fact for a country that is 92% Muslim.
[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mand%C3%A9_peoples_of_Africa Fascinating!!
[5] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Senegal
[6] Classification of individual languages within the Mandé language family can be a very tenuous exercise. They tend to move along a spectrum, rather than having strictly defined limits, and many dialects that are officially considered to be separate languages are in fact fully mutually intelligible to the native speaker. I wonder very often here what officially defines a language.

[7] Futa Jallon and the Jaxhanke Clerical Tradition. Sanneh, Lamin. Journal of Religion in Africa, Vol. 1 (1981), pp. 38-64.
[8] Ibid.
[9] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fouta_Djallon
[10] ibid
[11] Mahmiud Kacti, Tarikhal-Fattdsht, and O. Houdas and M. Delafosse, Paris, 1964, 314, Ar. text 179.
[12] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jakhanke_people
[13] When I am in Dakar or anywhere out west with other volunteers this is a source of constant hilarity. They will strike up conversations in Pulaar or Wolof with fruit sellers, who will then start talking to me. “Je parle Jaxanké”, I say, and they often have no idea what I am talking about. Sometimes they say, no no, it’s pronounced jaxatu, (which is the name of an eggplant like vegetable) and sorry we are all out.
[14] It’s the only horse I’ve ever seen in Kedougou. We have sleeping sickness here, and normally they cannot survive, but is vaccinated, and my dad has the supplies to continue vaccinating it each year. I named it Muktar and have been riding it around my village, to the delight of the little kids.

No comments:

Post a Comment